Screw pile underpinning and concrete underpinning both carry a footing’s load down past the soil that is moving, but they get there differently: concrete underpinning digs pits under the footing and fills them with concrete, while screw piles are steel shafts screwed into the ground by machine and bracketed to the footing. Neither is better in general. The structural engineer chooses from the soil information, the depth to firm ground, the access and the structure, and quotes that use different methods only compare fairly when each is priced from that design.
The two methods in plain English
Concrete underpinning (mass concrete, or beam and base) excavates short sections under the existing footing, one at a time in the engineer’s sequence, and fills each pit with concrete so the footing bears on deeper ground. It can be dug by hand where a machine cannot reach. Mainmark, an underpinning contractor, describes traditional underpinning as “labour intensive” with “large excavations”, and says on its own Sydney page that concrete “can take several days to get to strength” (Mainmark, Sydney underpinning and house re-levelling). The concrete underpinning method guide covers the steps.
Screw pile underpinning (also called screw piers or helical piles) uses a steel shaft with helical plates near the tip, screwed in by a hydraulic drive to the depth or resistance the engineer specifies. A bracket then ties the pile to the footing, slab edge or bearer. Piles are a recognised footing type: the Australian Standard for piling, AS 2159-2009 Piling: Design and installation (shown as “Pending Revision” on the Standards Australia store), includes sections on steel screw piles and installation by screwing. The steel screw piles guide covers installation in more detail.
Side-by-side comparison table
| Feature | Screw pile underpinning | Concrete underpinning |
|---|---|---|
| How it is installed | Screwed in by a hydraulic drive head, then bracketed | Pits dug under the footing in sequence, then filled with concrete |
| Excavation and spoil | Small: a hole at each bracket position | Larger: soil from every pit is removed |
| Access | Needs room for the machine and drive head | Can be dug by hand in tight spaces |
| When it can take load | Once bracketed and checked; no concrete to cure | After the concrete has gained strength |
| Depth | Set by the engineer; reaching depth does not mean a deeper pit | Deeper means more digging and more concrete per pit |
| Main limits | Rock, rubble or old fill can stop a pile short | Labour, spoil handling, and shoring for deeper pits |
| Proof it was installed to design | Installation records (depth and torque) checked by the engineer | Engineer inspection of the pit before the pour |
How much of the footing needs treatment (one corner or a whole wall) usually moves the total more than the method; see underpinning depth and partial underpinning for how the scope is set.
Where screw piles win: speed, mess, access
- Speed on site. With no concrete to cure, a pile can usually be connected and loaded in the same visit, so the time on site can be shorter. The engineer’s hold points still apply.
- Less mess. No pits along the wall and little spoil to remove, which matters where paving, gardens or neighbouring footings are close. CSIRO warns that excavation around footings “must be properly engineered”, because removing supporting soil causes subsidence (CSIRO, Foundation Maintenance and Footing Performance).
- Depth without deeper pits. Where firm ground is deep, a pile goes further down without a deeper excavation. Mainmark says on the same page that deeper underpins cost more because each excavation needs shoring.
- Access for the machine. Where compact equipment can reach the wall, installation is efficient; where it cannot, this advantage disappears.
Where concrete still wins: hand access and simple materials
- No machine needed. A pit can be dug by hand under a low floor or along a narrow side path where no rig fits.
- Simple materials. Concrete and reinforcement, with no proprietary pile or bracket to source.
- Shallow firm ground. Where firm ground or rock is close to the surface, a short concrete pit may bear on it directly, while a screw pile may stop short of its design torque.
- Cost per pin. Concrete is often assumed to be cheaper per pin on easy sites, but no independent publisher found compares the two methods per pin, so treat any claim either way as something to test with quotes priced from the same engineer’s design.
Site conditions that rule one out
- Rock, rubble or old footings at shallow depth can stop a screw pile before it reaches the design depth or torque; a concrete pit can be dug past or onto the obstruction.
- No machine access rules out most screw pile installations.
- A broad zone of poor ground across the site, rather than one dropped corner, may suit neither; ground improvement such as jet grouting is a separate category.
- A voided or settled slab rather than a failed strip footing may suit resin injection better; see the resin injection underpinning guide.
- Saline or aggressive ground: ask what corrosion protection the engineer specifies for steel piles. Wagga Wagga City Council describes urban salinity as one of the city’s most significant land degradation concerns (Wagga Wagga City Council, Urban Salinity).
Neither method fixes the cause. A pile or a pit carries the load past the soil that moves; leaks, downpipes and garden watering near the walls still need fixing, or the parts of the house that are not underpinned keep moving.
How the engineer chooses, and what drives the cost
The engineer works from the crack pattern, floor levels and soil information. CSIRO notes that soil classification “is provided by a geotechnical report”. NSW soil survey maps rate most of the land under Wagga’s suburbs as low to moderate foundation hazard, locally higher near drainage lines and on saline or sloping ground (Soil Landscapes of the Wagga Wagga 1:100,000 Sheet), but only a site test gives the depth and class for one house.
hipages lists the underpinning method among the main cost factors, saying mass concrete, screw piers and chemical underpinning each have different costs because of “variations in materials, methods and equipment” (hipages, How much does underpinning cost). No independent guide publishes a screw pile price for Wagga or the Riverina. The underpinning cost guide lists the published underpinning ranges with each publisher and date. A contractor who recommends the same method for every house may be reflecting their own equipment; a good recommendation explains the choice in terms of the site. See underpinning for the service itself.
FAQs
Is screw pile underpinning as good as concrete underpinning?
Both are established methods, and either is only as good as the engineer’s design and the installation. Ask for the design, the installation records and the engineer’s sign-off whichever method is used.
How do I compare quotes that use different methods?
Compare what each delivers: the number and position of piers or piles, the depth or torque, the engineering basis, what is excluded, and the making good. Quotes priced from the same engineer’s design can be compared; quotes where each contractor set their own scope cannot.
Do screw piles need maintenance over time?
They are buried and not normally maintained, but steel durability depends on the ground. Ask what coating or corrosion allowance the engineer specifies for your soil, and keep the installation records.
Can screw piles be removed if needed?
A screw pile can in principle be unscrewed, unlike a concrete pit, which helps if a pile meets an obstruction and must be moved during installation. Removing piles from finished work is unusual.
How long does screw pile underpinning take?
No independent source publishes a standard duration. The number of piles, access, the engineer’s hold points and any re-levelling set the program; the guide to how long underpinning takes explains what to ask for in writing.
Sources
- Mainmark, Sydney underpinning and house re-levelling: a contractor’s own statements on traditional underpinning, curing and shoring. Checked 16/11/2026.
- Standards Australia store, AS 2159-2009 Piling: Design and installation: scope and contents, including steel screw piles. Checked 16/11/2026.
- CSIRO, Foundation Maintenance and Footing Performance (2024): engineered excavation and soil classification. Checked 16/11/2026.
- hipages, How much does underpinning cost: method as a cost factor (last updated 23 January 2026). Checked 16/11/2026.
- Wagga Wagga City Council, Urban Salinity: urban salinity. Checked 16/11/2026.
- NSW Government, Soil Landscapes of the Wagga Wagga 1:100,000 Sheet: foundation hazard ratings. Checked 16/11/2026.