Neither a concrete slab nor a timber floor on stumps is better on clay in every case. Both work when they are designed for the site’s soil class and the ground around them is kept at an even moisture, and both can move when it is not. The real differences are how each one shows movement and how each is repaired: stumped floors are usually fixed by restumping and re-levelling from underneath, while slabs and strip footings are fixed by underpinning to an engineer’s design.
The two systems
Slab-on-ground. A reinforced concrete slab is both floor and foundation, usually stiffened with edge and internal beams. For new homes, the National Construction Code requires the foundation to be “classified in accordance with AS 2870”, and sites classed H, E or P must be designed to AS 2870 itself (ABCB, NCC 2022 Housing Provisions Part 4.2). AS 2870-2011 sets out how a site is classified and how footings and slabs are designed for it (Standards Australia, AS 2870-2011).
Suspended timber floor on stumps. Floorboards sit on joists, joists on bearers, and bearers on rows of stumps, each on its own small footing. Original stumps were often timber; replacements are usually concrete or galvanised steel. There is a crawl space underneath for inspection.
How each moves on reactive clay
CSIRO’s homeowner guide explains that clay swelling “first lifts the most exposed extremities of the footing system” and drying lowers the external footings first, so movement starts at the perimeter of any house (CSIRO, Foundation Maintenance and Footing Performance).
- A slab tends to move as a stiff unit. When the edge dries and drops or wets and rises relative to the middle, the slab domes or dishes and the brickwork on it cracks, typically at corners and around doors and windows. The guide to edge lift and edge fall explains both.
- A stumped floor moves stump by stump. CSIRO says framed buildings are less likely to crack from swell and shrink than masonry ones because of their flexibility, and that their main risk comes from the isolated pier footings. Isolated piers rise more easily than wall footings when soil swells, “creating noticeable doming of flooring”, and piers that lose support can lose contact with the bearers so the floor becomes bouncy.
Side by side
| Concrete slab | Timber floor on stumps | |
|---|---|---|
| How movement shows | Cracked brickwork and render, sticking doors, tiles cracking | Bouncy or patchy floors, sloping floors, sticking doors |
| Access for inspection | None under the slab | Crawl space under the floor |
| Usual structural repair | Underpinning to an engineer’s design | Restumping and re-levelling |
| Ongoing checks | Drainage and moisture at the perimeter | Stumps, bearers, subfloor ventilation and termites |
| Moisture risks | Gardens, leaks and ponding at the slab edge | The same at the perimeter, plus damp or poorly ventilated subfloors |
CSIRO notes that poor subfloor ventilation lets condensation build up and that high subfloor humidity suits pests including termites, which is the stumped floor’s extra maintenance item.
Which is easier to repair?
Usually the stumped floor, because the failed stumps can be seen and replaced from underneath and the floor re-levelled in the same job; see restumping and reblocking. Slab repairs need more diagnosis (which edge, how far, why) and an engineer’s design, then underpinning and making good of cracks. Many older houses have both: an original stumped floor and a later slab extension, each needing its own treatment. The guide to restumping versus underpinning sets out which applies.
Cost depends on scope rather than foundation type alone; the underpinning cost guide lists published ranges for both restumping and underpinning.
Buying a house: what to check
On a stumped house: can you get under the floor; what condition are the stumps and bearers in; have they been replaced, and is there paperwork? On a slab house: is there a soil classification from construction; does water drain away from the slab; are there diagonal cracks in the brickwork? A pre-purchase structural inspection answers these before you commit.
Frequently asked questions
Should a new house in Wagga be built on a slab or a suspended floor?
That is a design decision for the builder and engineer once the site is classified; the soil report sets the class and the footing design follows it.
My stumped house has sloping floors and my neighbour’s slab house has cracks. Which is worse?
Neither, necessarily. Both are showing ground movement in the way their structure allows: the slab through cracks in rigid brickwork, the timber floor through slope and bounce.
Can a stumped house be converted to a slab?
It is possible but means removing the floor structure and rebuilding it, so it is rarely the practical choice; restumping and re-levelling is the usual repair. An engineer can advise on a specific house.
Sources
- ABCB, NCC 2022 Housing Provisions Part 4.2: site classification to AS 2870 and H, E and P sites; checked 15/11/2026
- Standards Australia, AS 2870-2011 Residential slabs and footings: scope of the standard (status shown as pending revision); checked 15/11/2026
- CSIRO, Foundation Maintenance and Footing Performance (2024): perimeter movement, framed and masonry structures, isolated piers, subfloor condensation; checked 15/11/2026