Guide

Soil Heave vs Settlement: How to Tell Which One Is Happening

Wagga Foundation Repairs is an independent referral service and does not perform or contract for the advertised work. Your enquiry may be referred to an independent contractor. Where licensing is required, the contractor's identity and licence details will be provided before you accept a quotation or enter a contract.

Settlement is a footing moving down; heave is a footing being pushed up. On clay soils both are mostly driven by moisture: CSIRO’s homeowner guide says the swelling of soil “creates an upward force on the footings”, while shrinkage “creates subsidence” that takes away the footing’s support (CSIRO, Foundation Maintenance and Footing Performance). Telling them apart matters because the fixes differ: settlement may need support added under the footing, while heave is usually fixed by removing the source of water.

The mechanics: what heave is, what settlement is

The subsidence, settlement and heave guide covers the terms in full. In short, per CSIRO:

Settlement happens when the ground under a footing loses volume or support. Causes include clay shrinking as it dries (from a dry spell, or tree and shrub roots drawing moisture), erosion washing soil away, saturation that makes clay lose “virtually all of its bearing capacity”, and settlement after construction as the ground compacts or consolidates.

Heave happens when the ground under a footing gains volume. Clay “slowly” absorbs water and increases in volume; common sources are prolonged wet weather, leaking pipes or taps, unconnected downpipes, garden watering near the walls, and roots growing under footings, which CSIRO says can exert “upward pressure” as they thicken.

CSIRO adds that seasonal movement is not usually noticeable unless there are prolonged rainy or dry periods, “usually of weeks or months”. Wagga’s own rainfall record shows how far the seasons can swing: the Bureau of Meteorology’s Wagga Wagga AMO station has a mean annual rainfall of 571.6 mm, with 1,019.2 mm in 2010 and 245.2 mm in 1967 (BOM, Climate statistics for Wagga Wagga AMO). That variation says nothing about any one house; NSW soil survey maps rate most of the land under Wagga’s suburbs as low to moderate foundation hazard, locally higher near drainage lines and on saline or sloping ground (Soil Landscapes of the Wagga Wagga 1:100,000 Sheet), and only a site soil test gives a home’s AS 2870 class.

Crack shapes: settlement wider at top, heave wider at bottom

A common rule of thumb is that a crack wider at the top points to the wall dropping at one end (settlement), and a crack wider at the bottom points to that end being pushed up (heave). It is a useful observation to record, but not a reliable test on its own. CSIRO explains why: because a building resists uneven movement, the forces are usually rotational, which “complicates the diagnosis because the visible symptoms do not simply reflect the original cause”. Openings, wall length and how the walls are tied together all change where a crack opens.

CSIRO says brickwork tries to span ground that drops away or rises, so cracks appear at weak points such as door and window openings. For severity, its reproduction of AS 2870-2011 Table C1 rates wall cracks under 1 mm as “very slight”, under 5 mm as “slight”, 5 to 15 mm as “moderate” and 15 to 25 mm as “severe”.

ClueLeans towards settlementLeans towards heave
Crack taperWider at the topWider at the bottom
Floor shape near the wallFloor falls towards the wallFloor rises towards the wall
TimingAfter a long dry spell, or near thirsty treesAfter prolonged rain, a leak or new watering
Floor shape across the houseEdges lower than the middle (doming)Edges higher than the middle (dishing)

A floor level survey measures the shape of the floor rather than guessing it.

Where in the house each usually appears

CSIRO says seasonal swelling and shrinkage “affects the perimeter of the building first”, then spreads inward. Swelling usually begins at the uphill end of the building, or on the weather side where the land is flat; shrinkage usually begins on the side where the sun’s heat is greatest.

  • Settlement from drying tends to show first at outside walls on the sunny side and near trees and large shrubs.
  • Heave from wetting tends to show near the water source: a leaking pipe or tap, an overflowing gutter, an unconnected downpipe or a heavily watered garden bed. CSIRO notes that even a minuscule leak “can be enough to saturate a clay foundation”.
  • On timber floors, CSIRO says isolated piers rise more easily than the footings under walls, which can create noticeable doming of the floor when the ground swells.

The tricky case: both happening in the same house

Different parts of one house can move in opposite directions at once: one corner drying beside a tree while another wall sits beside a leaking tap. CSIRO says swelling under a house is more likely to be uneven, “creating a difference rather than a disappearance in symptoms”, which is why one crack’s shape cannot set the repair for the whole house. The drainage and moisture correction and underpinning services are sometimes needed together.

Combined movement on slab homes: edge-fall plus interior heave, and the post-tree-removal pattern

Dishing and doming. CSIRO describes wet periods lifting the outside footings first, so the floor looks slightly dished, with doors binding on the floor or door head and cornice mitres cracking. As the soil dries, the outside footings drop first, the middle is left relatively high, and “the doming is accentuated”. The guide to edge lift and edge fall covers this for slabs.

After a tree is removed. CSIRO says growing roots exert upward pressure, while soil dried by roots “will tend to remove support from under footings”. Taking a tree away can let dried soil take up water again, which may reverse the movement on that side. CSIRO calls soil drying by trees “a more complex issue” and says professional advice may be needed before removing or relocating the tree. In Wagga, Council says penalties or prosecution can apply to someone who damages or removes a tree without consent, so check whether consent is needed first (Wagga Wagga City Council, Private Trees).

Why the fix differs between heave and settlement

Settlement: where an engineer finds a footing has lost support and is still moving, the structural fix is usually to add support below it, for example underpinning, screw piles or resin injection, together with dealing with whatever dried or eroded the soil.

Heave: the cause is water, so the first step is to remove it. CSIRO says that where movement is caused by a water service, roof plumbing, sewer or stormwater failure, “the remedy is to repair the problem”, and recommends a paving apron at least 900 mm wide “(more in highly reactive soil)” falling away from the walls at a minimum of 1:60. Adding piers under a footing that is being pushed up does not stop the clay swelling. Whether any re-levelling follows is the engineer’s call once the moisture is under control.

CSIRO also warns against packing the gap that opens between a bearer and a pier in a dry spell: when the ground swells again, the extra packing can push the floor “up into an accentuated dome”. A foundation inspection before any repair avoids treating one problem as the other.

FAQs

Can heave and settlement happen on the same property?

Yes. One part can dry and settle while another is wetted and lifts, so an inspection should look at every moisture source before a repair is specified.

My walls have cracks that are wider at the top. Does that definitely mean settlement?

No. It is a clue that fits settlement, but CSIRO notes that the forces in a building are usually rotational, so symptoms “do not simply reflect the original cause”. Floor levels, timing and moisture sources need to be read with it.

Is heave as common as settlement in Wagga?

No source publishes how often each occurs in Wagga. On any one house, the trigger is usually local, such as a leak, a garden bed, a tree or a long dry or wet spell.

Does heave damage fix itself when the soil dries out?

Partly at best: CSIRO says cracking that opened while the soil swelled “is likely to at least partly remain” after it dries.

How do I know if my floor is sloping from heave or settlement?

Measure it. A floor level survey shows whether the edges sit lower than the middle or higher, and where; read alongside the cracks and the moisture sources, that tells the inspector which way the footing moved.

Request a quote

Sources

Last reviewed 16/11/2026. How these pages are researched and corrected.

More guides

Soil Testing Before Building in the Riverina: What You Need to Know

Why a new home or extension in the Riverina needs an AS 2870 site classification, what a soil test involves, what the…

View

Steel Screw Piles for Deep Foundation Support in Wagga Wagga

How steel screw piles underpin a house: how they are installed, what the engineer specifies, when they suit, the NSW…

View

Stepped Cracks in Brick Walls: What They Actually Mean

Why brickwork cracks in steps, what the AS 2870 crack categories say about width, how to monitor a stepped crack and…

View

More on this topic

Request a quote

Tell us about the job and an independent local contractor can quote it.

Get a Quote